Wikipedia 101: Wikiprojects

One of the ways that pagans can work on getting more accurate information about our religions in Wikipedia is together, particularly through onsite “wikiprojects.” It’s an important way that volunteer editors organize to collaborate on a given subject. There is a wikiproject dedicated to neopaganism, into which is lumped all of the earth-centric, polytheist, and other religions that are considered “pagan” in the most inclusive sense that’s typically used. (I didn’t decide on this scope; I’m just reporting it.)

Collaborating on Wikipedia is done in the same way everything is on that site: decisions are made by consensus, with discussions written out in the way early online forums were organized. This privileges people with a lot of time on their hands, because the longer the discussion continues the more words are written, and therefore understanding all of the points made in a very popular discussion can take hours. It also gives an advantage to people with a high level of reading comprehension, because editors tend to use words like “tendentious” during their discussions. This makes sense, given that the typical volunteer editor is a middle-aged, English-speaking white guy with a college education.

On the other hand, this is one of the most transparent forms of collaboration out there, because every change made to a discussion can be looked at—just like every edit to an article can be reviewed—by those who have the time and the inclination. While it’s not difficult to find bias (often simply because of the high ratio of middle-aged, English-speaking white men among editors), we only know it’s there because of this level of transparency. You could sift through [history of edits] to discover every single change I’ve made to articles, as well as the comments I have added to any discussion. There are a few things most people cannot see, such as edits I’ve made to pages that were since deleted, but mostly everything is available to anyone, whether they have an account on the site or not.

From what I can tell, the neopaganism wikiproject is not especially active, but I don’t think it would take much to change that. It reminds me of sitting in a bar on a Friday night and watching a succession people show up in twos and threes, each group leaving before the next arrived because the place was dead. I imagine there are a number of editors watching for activity on those pages. The best way to stir up interest is to begin editing relevant articles.

This is a good time to make meaningful contributions to the largest online encyclopedia about pagan and polytheist cultures and practices. In the broader world, misinformation and disinformation spread quickly, and working to improve encyclopedia articles about our practices is one way to offset that trend for the sake of our overlapping communities. Collectively, we have developed a corpus of reliable sources that can be drawn upon for this work, but no one individual is familiar with them all. Collaboration is the foundation upon which Wikipedia is built, and we can build upon that foundation to ensure that our traditions are chronicled.

Interested in helping? Here’s some steps you might take:

This post is part of a series on Wikipedia for Pagans, a series of tutorials about and reports on why Pagans should edit Wikipedia.

Paganism, depression, silence

When I was accepted as a presenter at the Sacred Space conference, it was a watershed moment for me: this was the first conference to which I had applied, and it was the one with the highest profile. It was also the first time that Sacred Space would be run concurrently with Between the Worlds since I covered the combined conference in 2015. For me, it was also profoundly informed by the pandemic: I applied in 2021 after the conference had already been rescheduled once, and despite it being the first opportunity I was given to talk about my work around pagans and depression, further rescheduling meant I didn’t get to do that until 2023 when it finally occurred. That was its own blessing, because I had been refining my message in the year-plus since Empty Cauldrons hit the bookstores.

Despite the expertise I was feeling, there is still a lot more for me to learn about my community, and myself. I’d planned a guided meditation for my workshop, one that included a solid 15 minutes of dead silence during which participants would connect with an ancestor. For a practicing Quaker like me, 15 minutes is just a quick jaunt, but I sometimes get nervous about introducing too much silence outside of that community. With my workshop scheduled for 9 p.m. on the first night—late for me, but perhaps not for many conference attendees—I convinced myself on the fly that folks who had traveled a long way might find themselves napping, rather than journeying. As a result, I shaved a bit of time off that part of the session.

It was with mixed emotions that I received feedback from one participant, who told me that the opportunity to meditate into silence was an exciting option—but one that wasn’t quite long enough to get the desired effect. I was frustrated that I had second-guessed my workshop design, but I was also thrilled to know that I can go deeper in this community, using spiritual techniques that do not include the tools that, as a pagan, I’ve been refining for 35 years. While pouring libations remains a daily practice for me, tapping into the power of silence has become more profound over time. I missed the mark slightly with that session, but I have redoubled my efforts to introduce silence to my pagan and polytheist co-religionists since. At Mystic South, I facilitated an hour-long session of silent, waiting worship; only one attendee of the dozen in the room was unfamiliar with the practice, and we went quite deep. At Changing Times-Changing Worlds my only presentation was again on ancestors and depression, and I allowed the period of silence to stretch to the full 15 minutes, and there were no complaints.

Retiring an American flag

American flags are accorded the respect that is given to a person; an animist like myself would say that this is because the American spirit embodied therein is a person. One example is the retirement of flags, which is essentially a funeral.

From the flag code: The flag, when it is in such condition that it is no longer a fitting emblem for display, should be destroyed in a dignified way, preferably by burning.

Retirement of flags is often done by members of veterans’ organizations, but it’s not restricted to them any more than is displaying the flag. Being in the military is a big deal, and our veterans are due respect even from those who are opposed to war. However, veterans do not have any special privileges here. Being a current or former member of the military does not give anyone special knowledge about or rights to the flag. The flag belongs to all Americans, and most Americans—including veterans—are ignorant about how to treat it with respect. I once worked with a veteran who was in the habit of taking down the flag and wadding it up in a corner of the desk—even if it was soaked with rain. There are plenty of veterans who have a greater knowledge of and respect for the flag, and there are plenty of other people—like myself—who keep those traditions but have not served in that way. I have had the honor of attending a flag retirement ritual performed by pagans at a private conference for many years; it’s the reason I bought a flag and the reason I choose to display it almost daily.

Burning is the “preferable” way to retire American flags, but there’s also a form of destruction-by-shredding that can be used for nylon and polyester flags. I recommend just not using nylon or polyester flags in the first place, avoiding the question of whether a flag is safe to burn by avoiding those nasty artificial fibers in the first place. I haven’t seen any evidence that flags made from the fake stuff last longer than natural ones, either. What I’d really like is a solid supplier of flags made from hemp, but I haven’t seen any legit American flags made from commercial hemp for sale yet.

While burning is preferable, options such as burying or recycling flags are also valid. What matters most is the sense of respect. This is an occasion not that different from a funeral, and can evoke somber and joyful feelings alike. The annual retirement ceremony I attend uses a ritual fire that’s already been consecrated to the elemental forces and land spirits, which helps set the tone. It’s not an uncommon act to cut the field of stars out of the flag as a way to release the spirit, but this is not universal. I like having an opportunity to tell the story of a particular flag, or to use the occasion to remember a deceased person.

Remember:

  • flags that have touched the ground or become soiled should be cleaned and purified
  • flags that are damaged should be repaired, if possible
  • taking down the flag every night is an opportunity to discover damage when it’s minor and easier to repair
  • retirement is for flags that are irreparable, or faded beyond use
  • a respectful retirement celebrates the service and life of a flag
  • any day of the year is appropriate for retiring a flag, just as any day of the year is appropriate for a funeral

If you have questions about the veneration and retirement of American flags, drop a comment here.

For my family, we take the flag in at night, before we sleep, and properly fold it. I wrote about folding the American flag as part of the magical battle for America. Folding the flag feeds its spirit and allows it time to rest and recharge. Prior to folding, I inspect it for grime and damage. That’s the reason why, in my view, that only displaying from sunrise to sunset is the “universal custom:” when a flag is left up on a pole constantly, no one is checking it for the damage that inevitably occurs. Identifying damage, repairing it when possible, and recognizing when a flag must be retired is essential to a respectful relationship with this spirit.

Dusk, blessing flag after witnessing its folding

One of our cats, Dusk (pictured), almost always appears to witness the folding ceremony, and we present it for inspection when complete. I do not know why Dusk holds American flags in such regard.

Fun fact: it takes 13 folds to get that triangular shape. There are several Christian-themed rituals which are built around that number. I don’t know of any published pagan flag-folding rituals, but I’ve written one myself, which I will share in another post in this series.

Folding the flag

For storage, American flags should be folded into a triangular pattern, as can be seen here and here. I also found a brief video demonstration, which can be seen here. On a practical level, folding the flag is an opportunity to inspect it for damage, which should be repaired if possible.

There happen to be 13 folds in this process, and that’s a number with all manner of associations. I’ve seen scripts that involve invoking one or another christian deity; I’d like to think that there are witches and pagans with some ideas about how to work with the flag and those 13 folds, too. Here’s one possible Hellenic invocation for folding a flag:

  1. fold in half lengthwise, representing the separation of Gaia and Ouranos
  2. fold in half lengthwise, representing the overthrow of Ouranos
  3. fold the striped end up to line up with the opposite edge, representing the birth and consumption of Hestia
  4. fold straight across, representing the birth and consumption of Demeter
  5. fold along the hypotenuse, representing the birth and consumption of Hera
  6. fold straight across, representing the birth and consumption of Haides
  7. fold along the hypotenuse, representing the birth and consumption of Poseidon
  8. fold straight across, representing the birth of Zeus
  9. fold along the hypotenuse, representing the overthrow of Kronos
  10. fold straight across, representing the dividing of the world
  11. fold along the hypotenuse, remembering the gift of fire from Prometheus
  12. fold straight across, remembering mortals now passed
  13. fold straight across and tuck, honoring the deathless gods

I imagine that there could be Hellenic folding prayers that invoke virtues, or daimons, or involve promises of future offerings in return for certain conditions being met. As discussed in the post on flag magic, in this context I only would request something that’s aligned with those nominal “American” values for which the flag hungers.

What would it look like for heathens to fold a flag—would it be similar to a sumbel or a blot, or would it be different than either? How about in voodoo, or wicca, or in discordian practice? I’d be very curious to see the different ways we can infuse this universal act with cultural context or sacred meaning. Symbolism can be tied to the act of folding as well as the number of folds. There might be a way to incorporate other factors, such as direction or time of day or year. Maybe someday it will be common to see flag swaps at pagan events, where you can bring a flag that was blessed and folded at Pagan Spirit Gathering when it was at Wisteria, and trade it for one that was flown over the capitol and dipped in the Potomac. There could be flags in every state in this union, flags touched by our gods and our spirits, bending the world to align this country with the values in its foundational documents. A spell like that, aligned with those values, would spread even to flags that are displayed by people who don’t support American values at all—the ones who put saw blades in rivers, for example—and use those flags to lift up the spirit of this land.

Trackbacks and comments with what you’d include in a flag-folding invocation are heartily welcome.

Paper route

I’m old enough that I held a job at 13 years of age. It was and is legal for children as young as 11 to work in New York, but the jobs a lot of kids my age got as their first mostly doesn’t exist any longer: delivering newspapers. There needs to be a certain density of subscribers to make delivering papers on a bicycle feasible, and I suspect that most of the people still getting home delivery had a subscription back when I was bringing papers to doors—and later knocking on those doors to collect the weekly bill.

The whole system depended on a bunch of young teenagers being responsible in many ways. My first route was for a morning paper. Around 4 a.m., the precise number of papers I needed were dropped at the end of my driveway. At thirteen years old, I got myself out of bed, got dressed, and biked around a route that covered about three miles before I got on the bus for school. Sunday editions required some assembly, with ad packages, leisure supplements, and the comics arriving a day or two in advance. Those were much thicker papers, and wouldn’t all fit in the milk crate that was secured to the front of my bike. Either I made several trips, or did the entire route on foot with a shopping cart full of papers stacked as high as my chin, and probably heavier than my eighth-grade frame when I started out while my father still enjoyed morning coffee. Fortunately, I had until eight to get those out. Thursday or Friday evening I would knock on every customer’s door and simply said, “Collect,” when it was opened. That’s what all of us said, and it’s what the kid delivering papers to our house had said for as long as I could remember, which was about three different kids. I kept track of what was owed in a little green book that I had to buy from my district manager out of my pay. As for that pay, I’d get a bill each week for the papers I’d delivered, and I had to leave that money out to be picked up on Saturday. What I was charged per customer was less than what they were paying, and most of them gave me a tip on top of that. I didn’t have a job; I was running my own business.

It all fell apart when I started high school: the start time was earlier, and the task of getting all those morning papers out without missing the bus became too much. After a month straight of getting to school late, my parents forced me to quit.

I was recruited to deliver a rival paper by a sweaty man driving a van in my neighborhood. I didn’t know the kid who had the route immediately before me, but I remembered it being someone with long, dark, straight hair. Evidently, that arrangement had ended, because when the driver of this van pulled over in front of my house, a kid my own age jumped out of the open side door and ran the afternoon paper to my door. That’s right, there was a paper that came out to be read over coffee or on the morning commute, and another that was printed with fresh news for people when they got home from work. The driver made eye contact, called me over, and asked if I wanted a job. I most certainly did, and I was given directions to a fenced-off lot on the main drag that I was pretty sure was vacant—and reminded to bring my working papers.

My parents must have realized that delivering after school was something I could handle, because they agreed to let me try again. (They apparently also had no problem with a sweaty stranger in a van asking their youngest child to report to a potentially vacant lot for a job, because I bicycled there myself.) For the second time, I got a route that included my own house. I again got the familiar green collection book, but everything else was a lot different. For one, this was no longer a solitary pursuit in the predawn darkness. I had to ride three blocks away to pick up my own papers, and there were tons of kids doing the same thing there. The lot I thought vacant was sandwiched between a body shop and a bank of stores that included a deli that this district manager—Mr. Ragusa, the sweaty fellow who’d recruited me from a van—sent a kid to to pick up lunch. It was mostly vacant, but for a trailer that was the center of the operation. The kid who got the boss lunch also helped with the distribution: getting there early, setting up the papers and supplements for each route, and helping get papers delivered when they were between delivery kids. Most of us had a turn being that assistant, and most of us only lasted a few weeks before someone else was tapped instead. It was a mini-hiring and -firing that didn’t affect having a route.

This route was all on my own street, which was straight as an arrow and probably no longer than three-quarters of a mile from end to end. I knew some of the customers already, but I realized I didn’t know very many people on my street at all. I was a kid, and anyone who didn’t have kids my age was invisible. That included one elderly couple who lived all the way at one end of the street; I knew and had played with their grandchildren since I was old enough to walk and talk, yet I’d no idea that these people existed before I started delivering papers to them. The family was Italian, and these grandparents who lived just a few houses from their adult child had certainly both been born in Italy. They both spoke with thick accents, I recall, and invariably butchered my name as they greeted me with boundless joy. I was sensitive and particular about how my name was spelled growing up, and I was vehemently opposed to a particular diminutive, but these people adding an extra syllable and doing something I couldn’t quite imitate with the ‘r’ never bothered me. Maybe I was just grateful I could understand them at all: I have always had a lot of difficulty understanding words presented differently, such as in singing, or in an unfamiliar accent. The only reason I was able to enjoy being in chorus is because I had a copy of the words to what we were singing; otherwise, I find it hard to bond with people over music because I can’t sing along. When it came to accents, I smiled and acted like I understood more than I did. I was not someone who wanted to draw attention to myself by asking questions, or to be accused of daydreaming because I asked a speaker to repeat those last three sentences. I still feel awkward when I have trouble understanding someone with an unfamiliar accent, especially since the problem is compounded by my fading hearing. I don’t like admitting that I don’t understand the words someone is saying, because it makes me feel stupid, or disrespectful. More recently, it can even be construed as racist. Since I often have these encounters, I have taught myself to be willing to admit that I’m struggling. I also make it a point to try to learn the pronunciation of names, but like those Italian neighbors of my youth, I find it difficult to reproduce sounds that I was never trained to hear in the first place. This was long before I learned in a college anthropology class that not long past infancy, humans lose the ability to distinguish subtle sound differences that aren’t common in languages they understand—which might be part of why it’s more difficult to learn a foreign tongue as an older person.

Hearing, as my audiologist reminds me regularly, is a function of the brain, not the ears.

Looking back through the lens of the 21st century, I believe I was witnessing assimilation in that Italian family. The grandparents were not white, but their children and grandchildren were. Italians were just another maligned group of brown-skinned immigrants not long before I was born, and my kindhearted elderly customers had surely endured as much discrimination as my own Greek grandfather. The metaphor that we were taught about this process in the United States was the “melting pot,” and we all wanted everyone to melt right in. What I now see as a transition to whiteness was undertaken not to “pass,” but to “become American.” It was a given to my younger self that everyone wants this, and that almost everyone could achieve it. No one ever explicitly taught me that this melting pot was generational, or that the goal was to breed out pesky cultural and melanin differences over time. Rather, I was taught that racism was a problem of a different time and place: it happened in the south, and only in the past, and it was terrible what happened to those people. Since good immigrants were the ones who worked hard to give their children the opportunity to fit in, the fact that there were entire communities of people who looked different and evidently did not fit in should have raised a lot of questions. Would have, if I’d been around anyone with an inclination to point them out, but no one in my circle as a child was having those conversations. I expect that real estate brokers would never have shown a house on my block to a black family, but apparently we were progressive enough to let in an immigrant couple with thick accents—at least since their white, American child lived on the same block.

It’s been a long time since I lived in that community, and it looks like the demographics have become even more extreme with time. 98% of residents there today are white, and the median income for men is more than 50% higher than it is for women. I grew up with one immigrant family on my block and one black student in my grade. I doubt the children there today have even that much diversity in their lives. This was never a community with racial deed restrictions like had been imposed in Levittown, 15 minutes away by car, but tradition carries a lot more weight than law in most human communities. Even if children growing up there today were running their own businesses at 13, and knocking on doors in the neighborhood asking for money, they still won’t be getting exposed to anyone with a different cultural background than their own. More’s the pity.